Verdict

CONSENSUS 2/3 · LOW

Official reports emphasize a large sell order interacting with high-frequency liquidity withdrawal; alternative accounts stress fragile market structure more than a single culprit.

Question

What was the actual cause of the 2010 flash crash?

Dissent

  • google · fixture-google · UNKNOWN

    Later analyses disputed attributing primary blame to one trader.

The crux

Whether a single order is the primary cause or a trigger inside a brittle microstructure.

By model

Slot 1 · openaifixture-openaiIT DEPENDS
  • CFTC/SEC joint report highlighted a large E-mini sell program.

The joint report centers a fundamental seller interacting with HFT dynamics.

Slot 2 · anthropicfixture-anthropicIT DEPENDS
  • Liquidity vanished as market makers pulled quotes during the cascade.

Microstructure fragility amplified the initial sell pressure.

Slot 3 · googlefixture-googleUNKNOWN · dissent
  • Later analyses disputed attributing primary blame to one trader.

Competing narratives mean a single actual cause is not settled.

Limitations

Historical market microstructure remains contested; model synthesis is not an official finding.

2026-08-01T12:20:00Z · schema 1.0 · history · public_atlas

This demo compares public-purpose questions across hosted third-party models. A Consensus Card compares model outputs; agreement does not guarantee truth. Korvo desktop runs consensus on your documents, on your machine, with your keys — and your workspace data stays under your control.

Download Korvo · How deliberation works